As a tax expert, I have come across various taxation systems around the world. But it was China’s tax systems, with their long history, that caught my attention. Among the many systems, the Mongol system of tax-farming in China is one of the most interesting and unique systems ever used.
The Mongol Empire under Genghis Khan conquered much of China in the 13th century and established the Yuan Dynasty, which ruled China from 1271 to 1368. During this period, the Mongols introduced a system of taxation known as tax-farming, which was very different from the systems used in previous dynasties. In this article, I will explain what the Mongol system of tax-farmingin China is, how it was applied, and what are its features.
The Mongol system of tax-farming in China
The Mongol system of tax-farming in China was a method of collecting taxes that involved auctioning off the right to collect taxes in a particular region to the highest bidder. The person who won the auction, known as the tax-farmer, would then collect the taxes in that region for a set period, usually three years. The tax-farmer was responsible for paying a fixed sum of money to the government each year, and any additional revenue collected above that amount was theirs to keep.
How was the Mongol system of tax-farming in China applied?
The Mongol system of tax-farming in China was applied in the following way:
- The government would announce that the right to collect taxes in a particular region was up for auction.
- Interested parties would bid on the right to collect taxes in that region, and the highest bidder would win.
- The tax-farmer would then collect taxes in that region for a set period, usually three years.
- The tax-farmer was responsible for paying a fixed sum of money to the government each year, and any additional revenue collected above that amount was theirs to keep.
- At the end of the three years, the right to collect taxes in that region would be put up for auction again.
What are the features of the Mongol system of tax-farming in China?
The Mongol system of tax-farming in China had several unique features that set it apart from other taxation systems:
1. Decentralization:
The Mongol system of tax-farming was highly decentralized, with tax-farmers operating independently in their respective regions. This allowed for a more efficient and effective collection of taxes, as tax-farmers were intimately familiar with the local conditions and could tailor their methods accordingly.
2. Incentives:
The Mongol system of tax-farming provided strong incentives for tax-farmers to collect as much revenue as possible. Since tax-farmers were allowed to keep any revenue collected above the fixed sum paid to the government, they had a strong incentive to maximize their revenue. This led to the development of creative and sometimes aggressive methods of tax collection, such as the imposition of new taxes or the raising of existing ones.
3. Flexibility:
The Mongol system of tax-farming was highly flexible, allowing tax-farmers to adjust their methods of tax collection to suit the local conditions. For example, tax-farmers might choose to levy different taxes on different products depending on local demand, or they might adjust the timing of tax collection to coincide with the harvest season.
4. Corruption:
The Mongol system of tax-farming was also highly susceptible to corruption, as tax-farmers were often able to use their position to enrich themselves at the expense of the government and the people they were supposed to be collecting taxes from. This led to significant resentment among the population, who often viewed tax-farmers as greedy and exploitative.
5. Economic Impact:
The Mongol system of tax-farming had a significant impact on the Chinese economy. On the one hand, it encouraged economic growth and development, as tax-farmers were incentivized to increase revenue by promoting trade and commerce. On the other hand, it also created instability and uncertainty, as tax-farmers might suddenly impose new taxes or raise existing ones, which could disrupt local economies.
6. Political Impact:
The Mongol system of tax-farming also had a significant impact on the political landscape of China. Since tax-farmers had significant power and influence in their respective regions, they often became embroiled in local politics and power struggles. This led to the emergence of local power brokers and the fragmentation of political authority, which contributed to the eventual collapse of the Yuan Dynasty.
Overall, the Mongol system of tax-farming in China was a unique and complex taxation system that had a significant impact on the economic and political landscape of China during the Yuan Dynasty. While it had some benefits, such as incentivizing economic growth and development, it was also highly susceptible to corruption and abuse, which created significant instability and resentment among the population.
7. Similarities with other tax-farming systems:
The Mongol system of tax-farming had similarities with other tax-farming systems that were used in different parts of the world, such as ancient Rome and medieval Europe. These systems were also characterized by the auctioning off of the right to collect taxes to the highest bidder and the collection of revenue beyond a fixed sum paid to the government.
8. Influence on Chinese taxation systems:
The Mongol system of tax-farming had a significant influence on later Chinese taxation systems, particularly during the Qing Dynasty (1644-1912). During this period, the Qing government adopted a similar system of tax-farming, known as the nian system, which also involved the auctioning off of the right to collect taxes in a particular region. The nian system was used to collect a wide range of taxes, including land taxes, salt taxes, and taxes on luxury goods.
9. Criticisms of the Mongol system of tax-farming:
The Mongol system of tax-farming has been criticized by some historians for its negative impact on the Chinese economy and society. They argue that the system created significant instability and uncertainty, which discouraged long-term investment and economic growth. In addition, they argue that the system was highly regressive, as it placed a disproportionate burden on the disadvantaged.
10. Modern-day relevance:
Despite the criticisms of the Mongol system of tax-farming, its legacy can still be seen in modern-day taxation systems around the world. In many countries, taxes are still collected through a system of auctions or tenders, and tax collection is often incentivized through the use of performance-based bonuses or commissions. While these systems have their flaws and challenges, they are often seen as more efficient and effective than other methods of tax collection.
The Mongol system of tax-farming in China has affected taxation in general
The Mongol system of tax-farming in China was a unique and complex taxation system that had a significant impact on the economic and political landscape of China during the Yuan Dynasty. While it had some benefits, such as incentivizing economic growth and development, it was also highly susceptible to corruption and abuse, which created significant instability and resentment among the population. Despite its flaws, the legacy of the Mongol system of tax-farming can still be seen in modern-day taxation systems around the world.
Read more about How Much Taxes Do Need To Pay For Importing Goods From China
